FANDOM


WikEd fancyquotesQuotesBug-silkHeadscratchersIcons-mini-icon extensionPlaying WithUseful NotesMagnifierAnalysisPhoto linkImage LinksHaiku-wide-iconHaikuLaconic

Someone's in trouble. The type of trouble can vary enormously - they could have been brutally attacked, raped, recently bereaved or blaming themselves for a catastrophe they couldn't stop. So now they're laid up in hospital with half their body in plaster, or mid-Heroic BSOD. Even the most cynical of viewers can't blame the poor soul for going a bit Emo.

But the writers aren't directing the audience's sympathies toward the victim but instead toward someone close to the victim. While the victim is recovering, their significant other is raving "I failed to protect him/her!" or "What happens to our relationship now?" Entire plot lines are devoted to how this person gets over the tragedy.

The real point of the story isn't "the victim was attacked" but "look how protective/self-loathing/angsty/loving the victim's friend is." The scenario is set up for the friend to get Character Focus. The person who was hurt is Collateral Angst.

Some stories make things even more peculiar by having the casualty apologise for being hurt. They will use phrases such as "being a burden" or "letting you down" to express their guilt. If the injured party is more upbeat and has coped admirably with the tragedy, they may try to cheer up their distraught partner, apparently oblivious to the irony of their actions as they do so. It's doubly strange if the victim is dealing well with their situation, but they then have to rescue their other half from the Heroic BSOD they've suffered.

When well used, this trope establishes the bond between the two characters, especially if the viewer recognises that Character A reacts more violently when Character B is hurt than if they themselves were. When badly executed, Character A may well look like an attention seeking diva, and the viewer may wonder if Character B needs this much drama in their life when they're trying to recover.

The only glimmer of hope for a "damage victim" is that they are important characters in their own right. Once they have recovered, things will be business as usual. It could be worse. If the wronged party isn't just injured, but dies in a particularly pointless way for the main character to angst over, they were probably Stuffed Into the Fridge. Someone who is living, breathing Collateral Angst - to the point the reader/viewer wonders if they're ever out of the hospital - and has little plot importance or characterization beyond that is a Disposable Woman. Of course, two X-chromosomes are required to qualify. Usually.

Examples:


Anime and Manga

  • Both Kisa and Rin are viciously attacked by Akito in Fruits Basket; Rin in particular is badly injured after being pushed out of an upper floor window. However, Kisa is more worried about the bullying she suffers at school, while Rin desperately searches for a cure to the Sohma curse in between hospital visits. Their love interests, Hiro and Hatsuharu respectively, angst constantly about their failure to protect their girlfriends. This cycle is broken when Hiro tells Haru what happened to Rin and, more importantly, why did it happen (she had told Akito she was the one leading the relationship, pressing Akito's Berserk Button to protect Haru; Hiro also blamed himself for the mess with her). This gives Hatsuharu the chance to both confront Akito on her bullshit and truly reach for Rin, convincing her to let him and others take care of her.
  • Shuichi from Gravitation is brutally gang raped by his boyfriend's rivals, actually submitting to the attack in an attempt to preserve the guy's reputation... despite the fact that said boyfriend, Yuki, has just dumped him. Shuichi's best friend Hiro seems to be the only one who takes the attack seriously, and he storms off to Yuki's house, both to reprimand him for the way he's treated his friend and to inform him of the rape. Yuki responds by threatening Taki, the leader of a rival band and the one who ordered Shuichi raped. After this, Shuichi himself seems to get over the rape remarkably quickly. A few chapters later though, it's Yuki who has a not-so-Heroic BSOD, claiming that it's his fault that Shuichi had to suffer (which is at least somewhat correct) and resulting in Shuichi comforting Yuki for the trauma Shuichi's rape inflicted on the novelist (which just seems plain wrong). In fact, it seems the rape was only there as an introduction to Yuki's dark past.
  • Sailor Moon's friends in both the first and last seasons of the first anime and the final volume of the manga die horribly so one can see how heroic Usagi is as she copes with such tragedy.
    • At times, the inverse would take place too: Usagi would be heavily sad and depressed over all the shit that goes on so the Senshi will angstily wonder why is their beloved Usagi being hit so hard with misfortune. A good example is the Stars episode where Rei finally makes Usagi spill the beans out on how Mamoru has not contacted her in months; one of the following scenes has Rei telling this to the girls, Ami confirming it after she contacted Mamoru's college and they tell her he never arrived there and then all of them mourn over Usagi hiding all of this under a Stepford Smiler facade.

Comics

  • The Green Lantern plot arc where Kyle Rayner's assistant Terry Berg gets gay bashed focused more on Kyle dealing with the angst of such a thing happening to his best friend, tracking down the assailants and scaring the bejeesus out of them, and eventually deciding that he was running out of faith in humanity and taking off for the stars. All while Terry, the one who actually got attacked, lay in traction.
  • One of Linkara's problems with DC's Infinite Crisis: Sue Dibney is raped, but the story completely ignores the issue of how the attack affects her in favour of focusing on how it affects everyone else. He goes on to point out the the comic's multiple narrators are all men, so while rape as a plot device (Linkara argues) is used by bad writers as "a thing that happens to women", an actual woman's take on the attack isn't provided, let alone the victim's own experience. Here's the episode for more details.

Fan Works

Film

  • In Gran Torino, Sue is beaten and gang raped by her own gangster cousins to get back at her, her brother, and Walt for standing up to them and challenging them, though the movie focuses more on Walt's reaction, partly because the attack immediately followed his own browbeating of one of the gangsters.

Literature

  • Little Women: It's painful for the Ill Girl Beth to die young; it's more painful for Jo to live without her Dead Little Sister. As Louisa knew firsthand.
  • A big part of Jodi Picoult's Handle with Care is the fact that while Willow is physically injured for most of the book (she has brittle bone disease), it's her mother, Charlotte, that does all the angsting -- and it's her mother's lawsuit that threatens the family, not Willow's disease. Even Charlotte is forced to realise that the court case she's set in motion is more about herself that Willow.
  • My Sister's Keeper seems set up for this trope. A young girl has leukaemia, tragic: we learn about her mother's constant state of panic and worry over looking after her; her father's shame over not being able to help and tendency to withdraw to his fire station and astronomy for peace; her brother's frustration at getting no attention from a family so wrapped up in her condition that he becomes a juvenile delinquent; and her younger sister, who was born for the sole purpose of being her organ donor, and who gets tired of being seen only as a means to keep her sister alive. The plot of the book focusing on the lawsuit that said younger sister launches to get medical emancipation to prevent her parents from forcing her to donate a kidney to her sister. Precious little attention is given to Kate, the actual girl with a terminal illness. It's worth mentioning that the book has a shifting first person perspective so that all of the above characters (as well as a lawyer involved with the case) have at least a few chapters which they narrate, which give us an insight into them, what they're like and how they develop over the course of the book... except for Kate, naturally, whose narration is minimal and saved for the final chapter and whom we mostly learn about through other people's eyes.
  • Abby comes down with a bad case of this in The Baby Sitters Club #104. Her twin sister Anna has scoliosis and needs to wear a brace, and Abby won't stop fussing and agonizing over how to "make it better" for her because "twins are supposed to go through these things together." Anna, meanwhile, is handling the situation fairly well and ends up calling Abby out on her pushy behavior.
  • In Lurlene McDaniel's Don't Die, My Love, Julie is more shattered over her boyfriend Luke's cancer diagnosis than Luke himself.

Live Action Television

  • Deconstructed twice in Scrubs:
    • When his best friend, Ben, is diagnosed with leukaemia, Dr. Cox doesn't cope well. Ben, in a rare subversion, actually calls him on this behaviour, pointing out that he's the one with the disease, and could use his friend's help rather than having to cope with Cox's issues.
    • Later in the series, Dr. Cox is traumatised by Ben's death. He's annoyed at how well Jordan is coping with the death of her brother, to the point that she has her best friends staying with her. They're out enjoying themselves while Cox openly grieves. Not until the end of the episode does he realise that Jordan has been seriously affected by her brother's death, and her friends are offering comfort where he failed to do so. Arguably, Cox was as close to Ben as Jordan was, but the theme of self-pity at someone else's expense remains.
  • House M.D. often treats House's addiction, disability and destructive personality more as a problem for Wilson than a problem for House. It gets to the point where even the idea of anyone feeling sorry for House because of any of these reasons seems ridiculous, even though Fridge Logic tells us it really shouldn't be.

Mythology

  • Most people feel bad for Hercules when he's pretty much brainwashed by his Wicked Stepmother Hera into killing his first wife Megara and children. Megara and the children who've just been brutally beaten to death, of course, are generally unnamed.

Video Games

  • Deconstructed to hell and back with Prince Dimitri in Fire Emblem: Three Houses. During his story path, the man's been consumed with Survivor Guilt and grief over the loss of his family, friends, and one of his knights during a bloody massacre in his past, that he witnessed and barely survived too. Over the five-year time skip he goes completely insane with rage and suffering kickstarted by finding out his First Love and stepsister Edelgard is the Flame Emperor and then his vassal and friend Dedue sacrificing his life to help him escape when he's framed for the murder of his uncle, and then he becomes obsessed with revenge, stating many times he can't rest until he's avenged the people he failed to protect. He's called out many, many times on this by his friends, comrades, and former classmates until his Parental Substitute Lord Rodrigue (also the father of both his companion Felix and his long-dead knight Glen) dies protecting him from a surprise attack coming from the grieving younger sister of a very sympathetic Anti-Villain that he wanted to torture to death even after he had surrendered (and Byleth had to Mercy Kill the guy to spare him). When this happens, he's forced to realize there's nothing he can do for the dead; the rest of the story is about him getting past this trope and learning to fight for what he believes in and those who still live.

Other

  • Many AIDS stories focus more on the (generally straight, while the party with AIDS is gay) supportive healthy friend character and how sad they're going to be when their friend is dead, rather than the person with AIDS themselves. Parting Glances plays it dead-straight, even with a scene in which (cool, accepting) Nick comforts Michael when he cries.
    • Rent is a little less supportive of this trope during "Goodbye Love," when Roger snaps a sarcastic "poor baby!" after Mark says that the reason he keeps himself emotionally withdrawn is because chances are very good that he'll outlive his friends with AIDS.
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.